The filed record
City Hall Hansard: Transcribing City Council Discussions for greater Accessibility and Transparency - by Councillor Brad Bradford, seconded by Councillor Paul Ainslie
The Public Gallery wrote no story on this item. What follows is the city’s own record of what happened to it, as filed: nothing on this page is summarised or scored by us.
The decision
2019-04-16 · Toronto City Council · adopted
As filed
City Council on April 16 and 17, 2019, adopted the following: 1. City Council request the City Clerk to report to the Special Committee on Governance, for consideration as part of the Committee's work plan, on the feasibility of implementing accurate time effective transcription of meetings of City Council and the various committees, boards, agencies and special committees and such report to include: a. a review of the transcription services used in other jurisdictions, including the Provincial and Federal Governments; b.
Show the rest of As filed, 213 more characters as filed
the cost of implementing such transcription services; c. a scan of technologies that could perform accurate time effective transcription services; and d. an analysis of the equity impact of transcription services.
The vote
Adopt Item · Carried, 12-8
The whole record, all 26 members
- Ana BailãoFor
- Anthony PerruzzaFor
- Brad BradfordFor
- Cynthia LaiFor
- Denzil Minnan-WongAgainst
- Frances NunziataAgainst
- Gary CrawfordFor
- Gord PerksFor
- James PasternakAgainst
- Jaye RobinsonAgainst
- Jennifer McKelvieFor
- Jim KarygiannisAgainst
- Joe CressyAbsent
- John FilionAgainst
- John ToryFor
- Josh MatlowFor
- Kristyn Wong-TamFor
- Mark GrimesAbsent
- Michael FordAbsent
- Michael ThompsonAbsent
- Mike ColleAgainst
- Mike LaytonFor
- Paul AinslieAbsent
- Paula FletcherAbsent
- Shelley CarrollFor
- Stephen HolydayAgainst
Every name opens that member’s record.
On the agenda
As the city filed it
Toronto ranks among the most open and accessible City governments in the world. While the Provincial and Federal Government have provided a proven, effective and accessible way to engage the public, Toronto continues to rely on a limited range of services such as our YouTube channel. This Motion asks City staff to report on the feasibility of transcribing City Council and committee meetings. Offering this service would remove one more barrier to residents understanding Council decision-making, provide context on historical decisions and programs, and go further in demonstrating Council's commitment to transparent, accessible government.
Show the rest of As the city filed it, 1,236 more characters as filed
The City's YouTube channel launched in 2014 and has had only 65,000 views. Many advocates as well as citizens rely on this service to follow meetings. Video records are a valuable resource for anyone interested in the work happening here at City Hall but from a user standpoint, transcription opens up a world of additional access opportunities. Transcripts are easily searchable, could be more easily translated in the many languages spoken by Torontonians, and integrate with a range of modern assistive technologies for our residents using accessibility tools. In a recent conversation, someone shared a valuable perspective: "we cannot make the public trust City Council but we can take every step to ensure our actions inspire trust". This Motion takes an important step toward inspiring greater trust from the public. As we have in so many aspects of City-building - we have an opportunity to be a global leader on transparent and accessible government. With new technologies available to us and an increasing burden on the City to make ever more complex decisions, it is critical that we give our residents every possible opportunity to follow Council decision-making, understand our processes, and hold our decisions to account.
Staff recommended
Councillor Brad Bradford, seconded by Councillor Paul Ainslie, recommends that: 1. City Council request the City Clerk to report to the Special Committee on Governance, for consideration as part of the Committee's work plan, on the feasibility of implementing accurate time effective transcription of meetings of City Council and the various committees, boards, agencies and special committees and such report to include: a.
Show the rest of Staff recommended, 334 more characters as filed
a review of the transcription services used in other jurisdictions, including the Provincial and Federal Governments; b. the cost of implementing such transcription services; c. a scan of technologies that could perform accurate time effective transcription services; and d. an analysis of the equity impact of transcription services.
On the record
More from this meeting
- Introduction and Enactment of General Bills and Confirming BillsFiled record
- Composition of Council's appointments to the Toronto and Region Conservation AuthorityFiled record
- International Accountability for Crimes of Genocide Against the Rohingya and Other Minorities - by Councillor Shelley Carroll, seconded by Councillor Kristyn Wong-TamFiled record
- Call to OrderFiled record
- Appointment of Public Members to the Dangerous Dog Review TribunalFiled record
- 14 Dewhurst Boulevard - To Permit Applications for Minor Variances - by Councillor Paula Fletcher, seconded by Councillor Shelley CarrollFiled record