The filed record
Regarding Toronto Paramedic Services
The Public Gallery wrote no story on this item. What follows is the city’s own record of what happened to it, as filed: nothing on this page is summarised or scored by us.
The decision
2022-02-02 · Toronto City Council · received
As filed
City Council on February 2 and 3, 2022, received Administrative Inquiry IA39.1 from Councillor Kristyn Wong-Tam, Ward 13, Toronto Centre, regarding the Toronto Paramedic Services and Answer IA39.1a from the City Manager for information.
The vote
Receive Item · Carried, 18-7
The whole record, all 26 members
- Ana BailãoFor
- Anthony PerruzzaFor
- Brad BradfordFor
- Cynthia LaiFor
- Denzil Minnan-WongFor
- Frances NunziataFor
- Gary CrawfordFor
- Gord PerksAgainst
- James PasternakFor
- Jaye RobinsonAbsent
- Jennifer McKelvieFor
- Joe CressyFor
- John FilionFor
- John ToryFor
- Josh MatlowAgainst
- Kristyn Wong-TamAgainst
- Mark GrimesFor
- Michael FordFor
- Michael ThompsonFor
- Mike ColleFor
- Mike LaytonAgainst
- Nick MantasFor
- Paul AinslieAgainst
- Paula FletcherAgainst
- Shelley CarrollAgainst
- Stephen HolydayFor
Every name opens that member’s record.
On the agenda
As the city filed it
Councillor Kristyn Wong-Tam has submitted the following Administrative Inquiry: I am submitting this Administrative Inquiry under Municipal Code S27-61 to seek information about service standards and staffing levels at Toronto Paramedic Services. I have been advised by members of the Toronto Paramedic Services who wished to remain anonymous as they have not been empowered to speak up publicly about their working conditions and their concerns about understaffing levels affecting response times for service calls.
Show the rest of As the city filed it, 4,921 more characters as filed
The paramedics state that their expressed concerns about staff shortage pre-existed the pandemic and that COVID-19 has only made matters worse. They maintain that years of chronic understaffing have left the City of Toronto unable to adequately cope with the service demands especially during call surges. On Saturday January 8, 2022, the paramedic union tweeted a #CodeRed stating that "No units available in the city at 18:38 hours tonight." In following media interviews, City spokespersons shifted the responsibility to province and explained that hospitals were taking longer to off-load the patient in transferring care from the paramedics to the emergency rooms. At this critical point, it is important that City Council understand the status of Toronto Paramedic Services and the extent to which deferred hiring, early retirement or departures, salaries, health and mental health, workload and staff morale are affecting our ability to effectively and efficiently serve and protect the health of Torontonians. Specifically, I am respectfully requesting the following information: 1. How many 911 calls have had a response time of 30 minutes to 59 minutes min. from time of first key stroke by call takers to crew arriving on scene with a transport vehicle in 2021 and 2018? 2. How many 911 calls have had a response time of 1 hour to 1 hour and 59 minutes min. from time of first key stroke by call takers to crew arriving on scene with a transport vehicle in 2021 and 2018? 3. How many 911 calls have had a response time of 2 hours to 2 hours and 59 minutes min. from time of first key stroke by call takers to crew arriving on with a transport vehicle scene in 2021 and 2018? 4. How many 911 calls have had a response time of 3 hours to 5 hours and 59 minutes min. from time of first key stroke by call takers to crew arriving with a transport vehicle on scene in 2021 and 2018? 5. How many 911 calls have had a response time of 6 hours to 7 hours and 59 minutes min. from time of first key stroke by call takers to crew with a transport vehicle arriving on scene in 2021 and 2018? 6. How many 911 calls have had a response time of 8 hours to 11 hours and 59 minutes min. from time of first key stroke by call takers to crew with a transport vehicle arriving on scene in 2021 and 2018? 7. How many 911 calls have had a response time of 12 hours or greater from time of first key stroke by call takers to crew with a transport vehicle arriving on scene in 2021 and 2018? 8. In 2018, 2019, 2020, and 2021 for each year what were the numbers of part-time staff and full-time employees that resigned? 9. In 2021, until the date of this submission what were the number of calls that were referred from Toronto Paramedic Services to Toronto Fire that in the end resulted in a required response from Toronto Paramedics? 10. In 2019, 2020, and 2021 what were the number of Alpha and Courtesy Code 2 priority calls that resulted in a CTAS 1 return by Toronto Paramedics? 11. In 2019, 2020, and 2021 what were the number of Bravo priority calls that resulted in a CTAS 1 return by Toronto Paramedics? 12. How many exit interviews were conducted with resigning or retiring staff vs number that resigned or retired in 2018, 2019, 2020 and 2021? 13. How does the pay of Toronto Paramedic Services compare to that of neighboring services such as Durham? 14. What was the average number of shifts worked by part-time paramedics in a 6-week cycle in 2021? 15. What specifically is Toronto Paramedic Services doing to retain staff and improve morale? 16. How has the growth of Toronto Fire Services compared to the growth of Toronto Paramedic Services in regards to new stations, additional apparatus, and number of crews being staffed? 17. Has the growth of Toronto Paramedic Services kept in pace with the growth of the city's population? 18. What are the benefits and goals of the part-time paramedic program? 19. How many calls were serviced by a neighboring paramedic service within city of Toronto boundaries in 2021 and 2018? 20. Was there an increase in paramedic calls relating to opioid use in 2021 vs 2018? 21. How many part time paramedics are currently employed with Toronto Paramedic Services? 22. How many full-time paramedics are currently employed with Toronto Paramedic Services? 23. How do those numbers compare to pre-pandemic years (2018/2019)? 24. Has the number of paramedics on WSIB/LTD increased in this time span as well? 25. At the time of this request, how many paramedics are deemed fit to work, not including community paramedics, paramedics in the staff support centre or in roles where they will not be responding to 911 calls? 26. What is the estimated timeline for when the staffing gaps in Toronto Paramedic Services and all other divisions will be fulfilled, the proportionate costs to implement, and an explanation of why it was not achieved sooner and/or whether it can be achieved in 2022?
On the record
More from this meeting
- Introduction and Enactment of General Bills and Confirming BillsFiled record
- Report on Councillor Mark Grimes’ actions relating to Adamson BarbecueFiled record
- Assumption of Services, University Square (Hucknall) Limited, Plan 66M-2493, Subdivision File: 04 138822 NNY 08 SB, 102-134 Hucknall Road - LitigationFiled record
- 847 Jane Street - Alcohol and Gaming Commission of Ontario Liquor Licence Application - by Councillor Frances Nunziata, seconded by Councillor Paula FletcherFiled record
- Call to OrderFiled record
- Ontario Land Tribunal Appeal of Official Plan Amendment 231 - 1235-1255 Lawrence Avenue West and 3-23 Benton Road - Request for DirectionsFiled record