The filed record
Trains Not Tunnels - Alternatives to the 401 Tunnel - by Councillor Mike Colle, seconded by Councillor Jennifer McKelvie
The Public Gallery wrote no story on this item. What follows is the city’s own record of what happened to it, as filed: nothing on this page is summarised or scored by us.
The decision
2024-10-09 · Toronto City Council · amended
As filed
City Council on October 9 and10, 2024, adopted the following: 1. City Council request the Province of Ontario to consider the feasibility of a high speed rail system instead of the disruptive and costly tunneling under Highway 401 running through the middle of Toronto. 2. City Council request the Minister of Transportation to conduct a cost-benefit analysis for the construction of a high speed rail system that would potentially connect cities like Hamilton, Toronto, Kingston, and Montreal - increasing the frequency of trains and significantly reducing travel times for Ontarians and reducing congestion.
Show the rest of As filed, 380 more characters as filed
3. City Council direct the City Manager to provide a briefing note on the costs (in present day value) and timeframe of similar tunnelling projects, including the "Big Dig" in Boston and the State Route 99 in Seattle. 4. City Council request the Government of Ontario to explore the feasibility of buying back the 407 Express Toll Route instead of building a tunnel under the 401.
The vote
Adopt Item as Amended · Carried, 18-2
The whole record, all 25 members
- Alejandra BravoFor
- Amber MorleyFor
- Anthony PerruzzaFor
- Ausma MalikFor
- Brad BradfordAbsent
- Chris MoiseFor
- Dianne SaxeAbsent
- Frances NunziataFor
- Gord PerksFor
- Jamaal MyersAbsent
- James PasternakFor
- Jennifer McKelvieFor
- Jon BurnsideFor
- Josh MatlowFor
- Lily ChengFor
- Michael ThompsonAbsent
- Mike ColleFor
- Nick MantasFor
- Olivia ChowAbsent
- Parthi KandavelFor
- Paul AinslieFor
- Paula FletcherFor
- Shelley CarrollFor
- Stephen HolydayAgainst
- Vincent CrisantiAgainst
Every name opens that member’s record.
On the agenda
As the city filed it
The Premier of Ontario is proposing to tunnel under Highway 401, a major transportation route used by hundreds of thousands of Ontarians and Torontonians every day as they commute to work, visit family, and partake in other day to day tasks or events. The 401 is one of the busiest and widest highway corridors in the world with over 500,000 cars and trucks using it daily. This proposal for a tunnel is expected to be incredibly costly, with preliminary estimates ranging far above $50 billion.
Show the rest of As the city filed it, 1,106 more characters as filed
This massive cost does not include the expected impacts on hundreds of thousands of Toronto residents, businesses, and industrial spaces spread across 15 of the City's wards and hundreds of residential neighbourhoods. A tunnel would be disruptive, costly, and is not guaranteed to fix the congestion woes we are currently facing. Instead, the City of Toronto and other municipalities in the region will be better served by a proven transit and congestion management solution used in over 30 countries for the last 60 years - a reliable high speed rail system. High speed rail will help Toronto and Ontario reach our environmental targets, significantly reduce the travel time between Ontario's biggest cities, further integrate residential and business hubs across the Quebec City-Toronto corridor and allow Toronto to benefit from the thousands of permanent jobs created through transit expansion. Canada is the only G7 nation that does not yet have a high-speed rail system. Ontario and the Greater Toronto Area deserves a second opinion before over $50 billion dollars are spent to tunnel under the 401.
Staff recommended
Councillor Mike Colle, seconded by Councillor Jennifer McKelvie, recommends that: 1. City Council request the Province of Ontario to consider the feasibility of a high speed rail system instead of the disruptive and costly tunneling under Highway 401 running through the middle of Toronto. 2. City Council request the Minister of Transportation to conduct a cost-benefit analysis for the construction of a high speed rail system that would potentially connect cities like Hamilton, Toronto, Kingston, and Montreal - increasing the frequency of trains and significantly reducing travel times for Ontarians and reducing congestion.
Show the rest of Staff recommended, 208 more characters as filed
3. City Council direct the City Manager to estimate the possible costs of tunneling under the 401, using examples such as the "Big Dig" in Boston and the State Route 99 in Seattle to inform their calculation.
On the record
More from this meeting
- Introduction of General Bills and Confirming BillsFiled record
- Appointment of a Toronto Integrity CommissionerFiled record
- Authorization to Release Section 37 Funds from 193-195 McCaul Street and 316 Bloor Street West Developments to the Housing Secretariat for the Affordable Housing Project at 35 Bellevue Avenue - by Councillor Dianne Saxe, seconded by Councillor Amber MorleyFiled record
- Call to OrderFiled record
- Ombudsman Toronto's Investigation into the Toronto Police Service's Communications About its Vulnerable Persons RegistryFiled record
- Credible Maximum Fines for Offences Contrary to Toronto Municipal Code - by Councillor Dianne Saxe, seconded by Councillor Jon BurnsideFiled record