Buried by deferral
20 Chatterton Boulevard fence exemption approved; resident requests deferral of Kingston Road zoning amendment pending cumulative-impact study
Scarborough Community Council approved a fence-height exemption for 20 Chatterton Boulevard in a routine vote. Separately, resident Debbie Hermas deputized requesting the council defer a Kingston Road zoning amendment until developers provide a combined microclimate, solar, and traffic study accounting for four major concurrent projects in the area, citing wind, shadowing, tree loss, and root damage concerns; no council vote on the deferral motion is recorded in the transcript.
The deferral motion requested by the deputy was not formally moved, seconded, or voted on in the recorded meeting. Hermas asked Councillor Candal to bring it forward, but the transcript does not show him doing so, and Hermas notes Candal had 'just left.' No council member is recorded moving the motion. The fence exemption was approved, but the Kingston Road amendment's status is ambiguous: the item was on the agenda for 'final approval' but no vote is recorded on the approval itself, nor on any deferral.
From the floor
“I was here a month ago to oppose a bylaw amendment which was passed against my recommendations. So, I'm here again today on another development.”Speaker not identified
“the Scarbo Community Council defer consideration of this application until the applicant has provided an updated comprehensive microclimate, solar, and transportation impact study that accounts for the cumulative impacts of the adjacent tree canopy that's going to be removed from the Bellamy project.”Speaker not identified
“These developments is four in the area that are happening and they're large developments. Our little area is adjacent to the Dorothy McCarthy trail and Scarbo Bluffs. With these large developments coming into single family homes area um it is going to cause a lot of damage to the environment to the community and also to the lifestyle.”Speaker not identified
“The wind study does not incorporate the 100 plus trees that are going to be removed from Bellamy Road south which is adjacent to that other development. So that's erosion, that's uh wind gusts um and that is um a problem for migration, not to mention transportation.”Speaker not identified
Also in this item
• Resident identifies four concurrent large developments in a small single-family area and claims individual environmental and traffic studies do not assess cumulative impact; argues for holistic review before approval.
• Wind study relied upon is from 2020 and does not account for tree removal from adjacent Bellamy project (100+ trees); resident contends this gap obscures actual microclimate and erosion risk.
The journey
What happens next
If the deferral motion is brought formally, residents can contact Councillor Thompson or other members to support it before a vote; Hermas's motion text is on the record and available for deputation or written submission at the next occurrence of this item.
Decision
20 Chatterton Boulevard fence exemption approved (5-0). Kingston Road zoning amendment deferral motion: no recorded vote or outcome.
Watch it happen
Jump to this item in the meeting video
Why is this story here?
Stories are ordered by how much weight a decision carries and how directly it reaches daily life. They rise as a decision date approaches and fall as they age.