Fine Equity: Balancing Toronto Transit Commission Fare Evasion and Parking Fines - by Councillor Paula Fletcher, seconded by Councillor Alejandra Bravo

The Public Gallery wrote no story on this item. What follows is the city’s own record of what happened to it, as filed: nothing on this page is summarised or scored by us.

The decision

2023-05-10 · Toronto City Council · amended

As filed

City Council on May 10, 11 and 12, 2023, adopted the following: 1. City Council express its support for the principle of fairness in fines related to City services. 2. City Council direct the City Manager to request the Chief Executive Officer, Toronto Transit Commission to consider taking immediate steps to reduce the ticket for non-payment of fares to a rate more in line with other City fines related to transportation.

Show the rest of As filed, 130 more characters as filed

3. City Council direct the City Manager to report directly to Council on this matter to the July 19, 2023 meeting of City Council.

The vote

Adopt Item as Amended · Carried, 10-8

For (10)Alejandra Bravo, Amber Morley, Anthony Perruzza, Ausma Malik, Chris Moise, Gord Perks, Jamaal Myers, Josh Matlow, Paul Ainslie, Shelley Carroll

Against (8)Brad Bradford, Frances Nunziata, Jaye Robinson, Jennifer McKelvie, Lily Cheng, Michael Thompson, Nick Mantas, Stephen Holyday

Absent (7)Dianne Saxe, Gary Crawford, James Pasternak, Jon Burnside, Mike Colle, Paula Fletcher, Vincent Crisanti

The whole record, all 25 members

Every name opens that member’s record.

On the agenda

As the city filed it

A basic principle that underlies the administration of fines and penalties is that there should be a proportionality between the offence and the fine or penalty. This helps preserve faith in the administration of justice. The fine for fare evasion on the Toronto Transit Commission is $195 ($235 once the other fees are added) and can rise over $400. The offence represents a loss of $3.25. In comparison, the offence for parking in a parking machine space without paying, or exceeding the time limit is $30.

Show the rest of As the city filed it, 425 more characters as filed

While the basis of each fine cannot be directly compared, the difference in fines between transit riders and drivers is quite stark and gives rise to a question of whether these fine amounts achieve the underlying objectives as part of the overall administration of justice. Ensuring that requested fine amounts are reviewed and reconsidered periodically would help restore confidence that the City is treating people fairly.

Staff recommended

Councillor Paula Fletcher, seconded by Councillor Alejandra Bravo, recommends that: 1. City Council express its support for the principle of fairness in fines related to City services. 2. City Council direct the City Manager to request the Chief Executive Officer, Toronto Transit Commission to consider taking immediate steps to reduce the ticket for non-payment of fares to a rate more in line with other City fines related to transportation.

Show the rest of Staff recommended, 129 more characters as filed

3. City Council direct the City Manager to report directly to Council on this matter to the May 10, 2023 meeting of City Council.

On the record

The item as the City filed it

More from this meeting

The whole meeting